T-Bills, CDs or Savings: Which Pays More?
Right now short-term U.S. T-bills and the best one-year CDs pay about the same. For a one-year U.S. example, a 52-week T-bill at 4.496% and top one-year CDs near 4.50% give similar pre-tax returns.
The short answer
T-bills often match or beat bank savings accounts. Top one-year CDs can tie or slightly beat T-bills. After-tax math and access rules usually decide the winner for you.
How each product pays
T-bills
T-bills are short-term U.S. Treasury notes sold at auction. You buy at a discount and the government pays full face value at maturity. Recent short-term auction investment rates were about 4.12% for 4 weeks and 4.496% for 52 weeks (Nov 2026 auction data). T-bill interest is subject to federal tax but not to state or local income tax in the U.S.
Certificates of deposit
CDs pay a fixed annual percentage yield for a set term. You get the APY if you keep the money to maturity. Banks post advertised APYs; top one-year CDs in late 2026 were around 4.5% to 4.75% for certain offers. CDs are FDIC insured up to $250,000 per depositor per ownership category in the U.S.
High-yield savings accounts
High-yield savings accounts, or HYSAs, pay variable APYs and let you access money any time. Best HYSAs in late 2026 were around 4.2% to 4.34% APY. The FDIC average savings rate is much lower, so compare top offers, not the national average.
Safety and taxes
Both Treasuries and FDIC-insured deposits are very safe in U.S. dollar terms. Treasuries carry sovereign backing and are considered effectively default-free for U.S. obligations. Bank deposits are insured by the FDIC up to stated limits.
Taxes matter. T-bill interest is taxable at the federal level but exempt from state and local income tax. Bank interest on CDs and savings is taxable at both federal and state levels. That exemption can make T-bills the after-tax winner in high-tax states.
This post uses rates from Treasury auction records, FDIC averages and rate trackers. For tax rules, check the IRS and your state tax office. Treat all after-tax numbers here as estimates.
Liquidity, penalties and market risk
If you need cash quickly, a HYSA is best. CDs make you pay an early withdrawal penalty if you pull money out. CD penalties range by bank and by term but are predictable.
T-bills are liquid on the secondary market. You can sell them before maturity, but price moves cause gains or losses. Selling a T-bill early exposes you to market rate risk. CD early withdrawal penalties avoid market risk but cost a fixed amount of interest.
How to decide: a simple checklist
- Emergency fund or frequent access: pick a high-yield savings account. You keep full access and avoid market or penalty risk.
- A known spending date: use a CD with a matching term to lock a rate.
- Short-term parking with tax sensitivity: use T-bills if your state tax rate is high or if auction yields beat bank offers.
- Want both yield and access: ladder CDs or stagger T-bill maturities.
Where to buy
T-bills: buy at TreasuryDirect.gov or through a brokerage. CDs and HYSAs: open accounts at banks or credit unions. Compare top advertised APYs rather than national averages.
Worked example: $20,000 for one year (U.S. rates, estimate)
This is an estimate to show the math. Use your exact tax brackets and the FreeToolr percentage calculator to test your situation.
Assumptions used in this example:
- 52-week T-bill yield: 4.496% (auction data).
- One-year CD offer: 4.50% APY (competitive advertised offer).
- HYSA offer: 4.30% APY (top easy-access offer).
- Hypothetical tax rates for illustration only: federal marginal rate 24 percent, state income tax 5 percent. Check the IRS and your state tax office for your exact rates.
Step 1. Pre-tax earnings on $20,000 for one year:
- T-bill: 20,000 * 0.04496 = $899.20
- CD: 20,000 * 0.0450 = $900.00
- HYSA: 20,000 * 0.0430 = $860.00
Step 2. After-tax earnings (estimate)
- T-bill taxed only federally: after-tax = 899.20 * (1 - 0.24) = $683.39
- CD taxed federally and by state: after-tax = 900.00 * (1 - 0.24) * (1 - 0.05) = $684.60
- HYSA taxed federally and by state: after-tax = 860.00 * (1 - 0.24) * (1 - 0.05) = $653.64
Interpretation of the example
- The CD and the T-bill end very close after taxes for this hypothetical tax mix.
- If you lived in a state with a higher state income tax, the T-bill's state tax exemption would widen the gap in its favor.
- If you need liquidity, the HYSA still makes sense despite slightly lower after-tax yield.
Use the FreeToolr percentage calculator to tweak tax rates and yields. Use the compound interest calculator for multi-year or ladder calculations.
- FreeToolr percentage calculator: Percentage Calculator
- FreeToolr compound interest calculator: Compound Interest Calculator
Laddering and matching term strategies
If you want both yield and liquidity, laddering helps. Laddering means buying multiple CDs or T-bills that mature at different dates. It spreads interest rate risk and gives scheduled access to cash.
Example ladder: buy four three-month T-bills or four 3-month CDs staggered quarterly. When one matures, reinvest at current rates or use the cash.
Laddering works the same for T-bills and CDs, but remember:
- CD ladder reinvests at bank-set rates and has early withdrawal penalties.
- T-bill ladder reinvests via auction yields or brokerage purchases and can be sold earlier at market prices.
International readers: a quick note
For the UK, short-term Treasury bills exist and DMO tender results in November 2026 showed 1-month to 6-month yields near 4.06% to 4.47% on some tenders. EU short-term yields vary by sovereign and remained lower in late 2026. In Nigeria and some Gulf states, local treasury bills can pay much higher yields than bank savings. Always compare local bill auction results with local bank offers and check local tax rules.
Common mistakes people make
- Comparing national average rates to best advertised offers. National averages lag and often understate the best available APYs.
- Ignoring state and local taxes. T-bills can win after taxes in higher tax states.
- Forgetting FDIC coverage limits and ownership categories when evaluating bank safety.
- Thinking T-bills are penalty proof. You can sell them, but price can fall if rates rise.
Quick decision map
If you need instant access: HYSA. If you can lock money for a set date and want a guaranteed rate: CD. If you want short-term market rates and state tax perks: T-bill.
Questions people ask
Are T-bills safer than bank CDs?
Both are very safe. U.S. Treasuries have sovereign backing. CDs are FDIC insured up to $250,000 per depositor and ownership category.
Do I pay state tax on T-bill interest?
No. In the United States, T-bill interest is federally taxable but exempt from state and local income tax. Check your state tax office for details.
Can I sell a T-bill before it matures?
Yes. T-bills trade on the secondary market. Selling early can produce a gain or loss depending on interest rate moves.
Which is better for an emergency fund?
High-yield savings accounts. They give instant access and no early withdrawal penalties. They usually pay slightly less than the best CDs or T-bills.
How do I compare offers quickly?
Compare APYs for CDs and HYSAs, and compare auction investment rates for T-bills. Use FreeToolr calculators to run after-tax and compound scenarios.
Sources I checked
- U.S. T-bill auction and data snapshots: https://soberyield.com/data/
- Rate comparisons and FDIC averages: https://yielddocket.com/where-to-park-cash/
- CD and HYSA rate pages and best lists: https://www.bankrate.com/banking/cds/cd-rates/
- Treasury bill basics and buying: https://www.treasurydirect.gov/
- UK DMO Treasury bill tender results (week ending 13 Nov 2026): https://www.dmo.gov.uk/umbraco/surface/PDFReport/GetDataExport?parameters=%26Tender+Date%3D13%2F11%2F2026
- PlainInvestor comparison article: https://plaininvestor.com/article/t-bills-vs-cds-vs-money-market-funds/